Skip to main content

Angels Too Soon: The School Fire of '58 | Chicago Stories

Angels Too Soon: The School Fire of '58

Our Lady of the Angels was an extremely tight knit, largely Italian parish in a vibrant community that flourished on Chicago’s West Side. But in 1958, tragedy struck when a fire broke out in the basement at Our Lady of the Angels and tore through parts of the building, trapping students and teachers in a terrifying inferno. The blaze killed 92 children and three nuns, shook a city’s faith, and stunned Chicago – and the nation – with sorrow. Now, 65 years later, survivors tell their story.

Historical photo of aftermath of Our Lady of the Angels fire with fire trucks and a lot of people in the street

Angels Too Soon: The Tragedy of the 1958 Our Lady of the Angels School Fire

The Our Lady of the Angels school fire in 1958 killed 92 children and 3 nuns. Image: Chicago History Museum

Illustration of The Great Chicago Fire

The Great Chicago Fire

On October 8, 1871, a fire broke out in a barn on the city’s southwest side. By the time it was extinguished, the Great Chicago Fire had killed 300 people, destroyed 3.3 square miles of the city, and left 100,000 homeless.

Go deeper

Chicago is a city that has been indelibly marked by tragic fires. The Great Chicago Fire took an estimated 300 lives in 1871. The Iroquois Theater fire took 602 more in 1903. And in 1958, a tragic Catholic school fire in the city’s Humboldt Park neighborhood took the lives of 92 children and 3 nuns. The fire at Our Lady of the Angels was an unimaginable tragedy that shook a parish and changed a community.

It’s often said that Chicago is a city of neighborhoods, but in the 20th century, it was also a city of parishes. With nearly 2 million Catholics in the Chicago Archdiocese in the 1950s, the parish was the center of the lives of many Chicagoans.

“At this time, people knew where you were from by what parish you belonged to, and that was an identifier, almost more identifiable than the particular neighborhood that they lived in,” Kathleen Sprows Cummings, professor of history at the University of Notre Dame, told Chicago Stories. “Where you worshiped, where you sent your kids to school said a lot about your demographic, your ethnic group.”

One such parish was Our Lady of the Angels. When it opened in 1894, it was a mostly Irish Catholic parish. But by the 1950s … Read more

An Extended Interview with Journey’s Jonathan Cain, an Our Lady of the Angels Fire Survivor

Jonathan Cain, who was a member of the band Journey, shares his own journey as a survivor of the Our Lady of the Angels fire and how music helped to heal him.

Photos from the Fire and Its Aftermath

The images below contain depictions of a deadly school fire that some viewers may find disturbing.

Firemen on ladders outside of Our Lady of the Angels
Firemen on ladders outside of Our Lady of the Angels Image: Chicago History Museum, Chicago Sun-Times Collection
A concerned crowd looks on
A concerned crowd looks on. Image: Chicago History Museum, Chicago Sun-Times Collection
Firefighters carry a body down a ladder
Firefighters carry a body down a ladder. Image: Chicago History Museum, Chicago Sun-Times Collection
Firefighters carry a body down the stairs
Firefighters carry a body down the stairs. Image: Chicago History Museum, Chicago Sun-Times Collection
A firefighter rescues a nun from the building
A firefighter rescues a nun from the building. Image: Chicago History Museum, Chicago Sun-Times Collection
Fire hoses cover the ground outside of the school
Fire hoses cover the ground outside of the school. Image: Chicago History Museum, Chicago Sun-Times Collection
A group of men awaits news on the fire
A group of men awaits news on the fire. Image: Chicago History Museum, Lee Balterman Collection
Grieving parents are comforted. Father Joe Ognibene is wearing the black coat
Grieving parents are comforted. Father Joe Ognibene is wearing the black coat. Image: Chicago History Museum, Chicago Sun-Times Collection
Nurses comfort crying women
Nurses comfort crying women. Image: Chicago History Museum, Chicago Sun-Times Collection
Nurses comfort crying men
Nurses comfort crying men. Image: Chicago History Museum, Chicago Sun-Times Collection
A nurse consoles a crying father
A nurse consoles a crying father. Image: Chicago History Museum, Lee Balterman Collection
Officials work to identify bodies at the morgue
Officials work to identify bodies at the morgue. Image: Chicago History Museum, Chicago Sun-Times Collection
>Parents await news at the morgue
Parents await news at the morgue. Image: Chicago History Museum, Lee Balterman Collection
Mayor Richard J. Daley arrives at the scene of the fire
Mayor Richard J. Daley arrives at the scene of the fire. Image: Chicago History Museum, Chicago Sun-Times Collection
The damaged building after the fire
The damaged building after the fire. Image: Chicago History Museum, Chicago Sun-Times Collection
Abandoned children’s coats among the damage
Abandoned children’s coats among the damage. Image: Chicago History Museum, Chicago Sun-Times Collection
Officials examine a scorched stairwell
Officials examine a scorched stairwell. Image: Chicago History Museum, Chicago Sun-Times Collection
Police inspect the damage
Police inspect the damage. Image: Chicago History Museum, Chicago Sun-Times Collection
A statue of Jesus was left burned in the aftermath of the fire
A statue of Jesus was left burned in the aftermath of the fire. Image: Chicago History Museum, Chicago Sun-Times Collection
Irene Mordarski still from video

From the WTTW Archive: A Survivor Recalls the Our Lady of Angels Fire

Irene Mordarski, a survivor of the tragic 1958 Our Lady of the Angels school fire that claimed 92 children and 3 nuns, recalls deciding to jump out the window to save herself from the fire and smoke.

Watch now

Lead support for Chicago Stories is provided by The Negaunee Foundation.

Major support is provided by the Elizabeth Morse Genius Charitable Trust, TAWANI Foundation on behalf of the Pritzker Military Museum & Library, and the Donna Van Eekeren Foundation.

Funding for Chicago Stories: Angels Too Soon: The School Fire of '58 is provided by John Salvino in honor of Al and Carole Salvino.