'Professor T' Recap: Season 5 Episode 5
Daniel Hautzinger
November 15, 2026
Professor T airs Sundays at 7:00 pm and is available to stream via the PBS app and wttw.com. Recap the previous episode.
Keep up with your favorite dramas and mysteries by signing up for our newsletter, Dramalogue.
Vashti Kane has just finished giving a golf lesson when she is shot on the fairway in broad daylight. Her father Matthew is the club’s golf pro; he found her dead when he went to tell her that her next lesson had been cancelled.
Vashti had mentioned breaking up with a guy with a hyphenated last name but complained that he had nevertheless been persistent. She said something about him being a con man who had scammed his boss. And a brand-new golf club for a tall man was found next to Vashti’s body.
A man’s body is soon found on the golf course, buried in a sand trap. He’s identified as David Ellis, who was just reported missing by his wife – and whose name appears on the back of a cipher letter sent to the police in a list that includes Vashti. The professor easily cracks the cipher – it’s the same one the Zodiac killer used – and declares it a distraction. Someone is trying to get the police to believe there’s a serial killer, but there’s not. No one else will be killed.
A cipher letter is also sent to a local newspaper, putting pressure on the police.
Nothing on either Vashti’s or David’s phone connects the two of them, and David’s wife insists that he both hated golf and wasn’t having an affair. Jack Miles, David’s business partner in a consignment business they started together in college, is insulted by the police’s questioning of David’s wife. He has known David since primary school; David, who was popular, took Jack under his wing.
David’s business was robbed a few weeks ago. A consignment of jewelry and watches was stolen the night it arrived, which prevented the business from getting insurance money for it since it hadn’t yet been appraised. They lost hundreds of thousands of dollars.
Vashti’s phone does show some interactions with an Alan Washington-Cove, a name so unusual that no one in the U.K. is registered with it. CCTV from a hotel where they met shows that “Alan” was an alias for David, and that Vashti and he spent a couple hours in a hotel room. When they emerged, she had a new watch.
The police piece things together. David was having an affair with Vashti, and also arranged the burglary of his own business; he sold his shares in it two years ago, so such a theft wouldn’t hurt him. He took a watch from the consignment before the burglary, knowing it would all be gone soon, and gave it to Vashti. She learned its source and got upset and broke things off. He tried to keep seeing her, buying a golf club and showing up at the course to “take a lesson” from her.
Betrayed, Jack decided to kill David and accidentally shot Vashti first instead. His employees say he was in his office at the time of the killings, but they just assumed that because the lights were on – they didn’t actually see him there.
But when Dan and Chloe show up at Jack’s office to arrest him, they find him dead, shot by the same weapon used to kill Vashti and David. They hear someone in the warehouse and chase him after being shot at, but he escapes out a window.
Speculation about a serial killer explodes, especially after Maiya receives a third cipher letter along with a scrap of cloth with Jack’s blood on it.
The professor is upset that he was wrong in his promise to Maiya that no one else would be killed. He thinks his critical thinking capacity has declined because of the app he is using to alleviate his compulsive behaviors. He blames Dr. Goldberg for this lapse, because he says he is using the app for her.
His aunt Zelda explains to him that he is misguided and has offended Dr. Goldberg; he can’t blame her. She urges him to apologize, but he doesn’t see a reason to.
Zelda has also learned from her husband the dean that the professor is considering leaving for a position in Boston, given his suspension for his “exploits.” She teams up with Miss Snares to try to convince him to stay, and to maintain his relationship with Dr. Goldberg. Miss Snares orders a bouquet for Dr. Goldberg from the professor’s account as an apology. By the time the dean tells Zelda this is a bad idea, it’s too late.
Dan is also facing headwinds in his relationship. Maiya is concerned his romance with Leonie could affect his career; she and Dan’s dad are both worried about what her father Chester might do to Dan.
Leonie goes to her father to confront him over trying to derail Dan’s career. He says he and her cousins – the sons of his brother, who died in police custody – see her relationship as “sleeping with the enemy.” She says she loves Dan and asks him not to make her choose; he tells her she doesn’t have a choice. She walks out on Chester and tells him their relationship is over.
Dan and Chloe go to tell Vashti’s father Matthew that they have solved her murder. He’s not in his office, but Dan notices the watch David stole for Vashti on his desk. He opens a drawer to find a gun – and then is attacked by Matthew. Chloe returns to save Dan’s life.
Matthew figured out everything after learning the value of Vashti’s watch. He killed Jack to avenge her, using Jack’s gun and then conveniently hiding behind the guise of a serial killer – which was itself a ruse by Jack to cover his own tracks. (Chloe has noticed that the third cipher letter was written by a leftie, while the first two were written by righties.)
The professor writes his own letter, declaring his desire to continue his relationship with Dr. Goldberg, and visits her to apologize. Zelda and Miss Snares watch from outside, hoping to intercept the florist before he delivers their misguided ruse. Dr. Goldberg tells the professor she has received a job offer in Boston that she starts in two weeks; he’s excited and kisses her. They retire upstairs, while Zelda pretends to be the doctor to accept the bouquet from the confused deliveryman.
Leonie tells Dan she cut her dad out – but that he is already retaliating. Chester has changed the locks on the gym she runs and won’t answer her calls. And he said he could ruin Dan’s career with a phone call.
Dan watches CCTV footage of Leonie’s gym to see Chester and another man change the locks. When someone walks up to try to go inside, Chester confronts him and ends up shoving him. Dan lashes out at Chloe when she interrupts him as he loops this video.